AS A WOMAN, writing a piece on ‘better men’ right now feels odd given the current state of the world. It’s tempting to go back a while, to the ’90s, to fictional figures like Stanford Blatch, George Downes and Will Truman. 

Now these, these are some men I feel great writing about.  

The importance of a gay male best friend in a straight woman’s life is something I feel deeply passionate about. There is a particular freedom in that friendship: the intimacy and comfort of male company, without the ambiguity that can sometimes accompany it. You can be affectionate, vulnerable, stay up talking until all hours, without wondering whether you’re ‘leading them on’ or misreading a signal, or whether your friend is quietly hoping to become something else. 

Gay men have often provided women with a rare form of male intimacy without the threat, expectation or negotiation of sex. And women, in turn, have historically offered gay men a space for emotional intimacy outside conventional masculinity.  

Take Julianne Potter, “Jules”, from one of my favourite films, My Best Friend’s Wedding. Essentially, the entire film takes the scenic route to championing the straight female-gay male best-friend relationship – a touching journey that is all about platonic love. Jules’ best friend was never really Michael (the guy she decides she’s in love with at the start of the movie). It was always, and will remain, George.  

A gay male best friend has a way of delivering some of the harshest truths, with no intention of inflicting hurt. Take George’s line during the turbulent and chaotic breakfast pursuit: “Michael’s chasing Kimmy? You’re chasing Michael? Who’s chasing you? Nobody. Get it? There’s your answer.” 

When trying on a toile for a wedding dress that wasn’t going to plan, I took my best friend, Daniel, with me to the fitting for a dose of harsh reality as I approached the very awkward decision to pull the plug on the dress. And, let me assure you, he delivered: “The back is beautiful, but from the front, you look like you’ve been hit by a bus”. It was just what I needed to hear, a hard-but-fair assessment that landed me in the safe hands of Alex Perry, who rectified the situation. 

Take Carrie and Stanford. Now, their relationship wasn’t what Sex and the City was about. But I believe it would have been more realistic had Carrie been closer to Stanford than was depicted. A group of four girls will no doubt have its trials at times, but Carrie and Stanford, that would’ve been safe from competition and judgement. 

So, what is it that many straight men could learn from their gay male counterparts? Perhaps it begins with simply liking women. That sounds absurdly obvious, but there’s a distinction between being attracted to women and actually liking them. Enjoying their company. Being interested in what they have to say. Developing friendships with them that exist independent of romance, sex or the possibility of either.  

These friendships offer women an experience of male closeness in which affection isn’t necessarily confused with desire. There can be physical affection, emotional vulnerability, brutal honesty and enormous tenderness without any of it having to mean something else. 

Recently, when I was sick, my friend Ryan dropped soup at my door. It was a small gesture, but one that stayed with me. There was no ambiguity to it, no wondering whether the kindness came with some other intention attached. He wasn’t trying to impress me, or hoping his care might eventually be rewarded. I was sick, he loved me, so he brought me soup.  

There is something incredibly freeing about being cared for by a man without having to question the motivation behind the care. To accept tenderness at face value. I wonder how many women have, at some point, second-guessed a man’s kindness towards them: Is he just being nice? Does he think this is something else? Have I accidentally given him the wrong idea? With my gay male friends, that calculation simply isn’t there. 

And perhaps that’s another thing straight men could learn from these friendships: care doesn’t need to be transactional. Intimacy doesn’t have to be a precursor to something else. Sometimes you can just bring someone soup.  

And the exchange goes both ways.  

For generations, gay men have had to construct their own relationship with masculinity, often outside the narrow version they were handed. If the traditional rules said men shouldn’t be emotional, shouldn’t care too much, shouldn’t be affectionate with one another, shouldn’t cry, shouldn’t talk endlessly about their feelings, well, being excluded from those rules may have provided some freedom to question them. 

Perhaps if Big had spent a little more time with Stanford, he would’ve learnt that open, honest communication is far better than brooding silence. 

Because perhaps being a better man isn’t really about becoming a different kind of man at all. Perhaps it’s about expanding the definition of what a man is.  

Recently, the headmaster at Sydney boys’ school St Joseph’s College, Michael Blake, delivered an extraordinarily poignant and eloquent address to all his students. To paraphrase it, he spoke about the line between a good man and a destructive one, and how that line falls way short of criminal behaviour. On the wrong side of the line is the sexist joke, the degrading photograph, the group chat that turns ugly, the moment someone is spoken about as though they’re an object – and, sometimes, the decision to say nothing, to condone the unacceptable.  

There will be moments, he told them, when being a good man costs you something. Popularity. A friendship. Your place within a group. Because, he argued, “character is not revealed when doing the right thing is easy. Character is revealed when you choose the right thing.”  

The men I love most are funny and kind and interested and emotionally available. They can be strong without needing to constantly demonstrate strength. They can sit at a dinner table with women and listen as much as they speak. They can give affection freely, tell you an uncomfortable truth when you need one and, crucially, stick around afterwards.  

At the end of My Best Friend’s Wedding, Julianne doesn’t get the man she has spent the entire film chasing. Michael marries Kimmy. Jules is left alone at the wedding, drumming her fingernails on the white linen tablecloth, having finally accepted that the great romantic denouement she had imagined for herself isn’t coming.  

Or is it? And just like that, George is there: “And then . . . suddenly, the crowds part. And there he is, sleek, stylish, radiant with charisma. Bizarrely, he’s on the telephone. But then, so are you. And he comes towards you . . . the moves of a jungle cat. And although you, quite correctly, sense that he is . . . gay, like most devastatingly handsome single men of his age are, you think, what the hell, life goes on. Maybe there won’t be marriage, maybe there won’t be sex, but, by God, there’ll be dancing.” 

There are inevitable troughs of sadness in life. But wrapped in a friendship that holds the promise of dancing . . . that sounds like the perfect way to move through them.


Related:

Better Men